If you happened to read our article on gaming video cables and you’re now in the mindset to improve your setup, you may be tempted to splash out on a fancy new HDMI cable. Tread carefully as there is a scam afoot.

Most consumables have a premium alternative, bread, milk, toothpaste, marketing companies spend millions every year trying to get us to buy near identical products at a higher price. In some cases the cost is justified, in the case of HDMI cables however, it is almost always not.

Here are a couple of choices you could make when buying a new HDMI cable:

  1. The Amazon basics High Speed HDMI 2.0 Cable £3.99
  2. The CSL Ultra HD 4K HDMI Gold Plated £10.85
  3. The IBRA High Spped PRO Gold Black £199

Now what I hear you ask is the difference between these three HDMI cables?

Well other than the length, materials and price. Absolutely nothing and if you fall for the more expensive of the three, the marketing people have got you hook line and sinker.

There has been a lot of research done into why the more expensive HDMI cables are a con but rather than bore you with too much technical data, the simple reason why they’re all functionally identical is down to one word. Digital. The signal emitted by an HDMI cable is purely digital, the data they send to your TV is done so in 0’s and 1’s. In very basic terms when your device wants to light up say a red pixel, it sends a 1 to the red pixel on the TV and it lights up. If it doesn’t want that red pixel to light up it sends nothing, or 0.

There is no in-between. A fancy gold plated HDMI cable cannot illuminate a pixel any faster, brighter or clearer than a standard HDMI cable, there is no 0.1,0.2 and so on, it’s all or nothing, 0 or 1, on or off, digital signals either work or they don’t. The sad thing is millions of people believe that they are getting a clearer picture using one cable over the other, it’s simply not true and a placebo effect probably brought on by the holes in their pocket. The signal cannot degrade either, nor can you be missing pixels or get less pixels with different cables. The HDMI standard is set up in such a way that if there is any fault in the signal, nothing will be shown at all.

I’ve even seen pages and pages of rants from people who have bought a cheap £2 cable and “compared it” with their £1000 Monster branded HDMI cable, with angry red faces and the caps lock key left on, they’ve sworn on their families lives that there is a clear visual difference between the two…I’m sorry, but there’s not, it’s scientifically impossible.

The fascination with gold plated connectors comes from the analogue age, where interference and less accurate machining processes meant that a gold plated connector could offer you a very slight improvement in shielding and conductivity, but even then the differences were so marginal you were still being taken to the cleaners. Sadly the trend lives on today and people are still buying into it.

What’s more alarming is that sales agents in stores are trained to up-sell these cables and they will flat out lie to your face about how they improve sound and picture quality, don’t feel too angry towards them though, the margin on these cables is huge so it’s only natural that stores will try to improve profits and those agents are doing as they’re told.

Premium cables also use robustness as a selling point. I guess it’s true that if a cable is wrapped in Kevlar and diamonds then it will last longer, but how often do you swing your TV set around the room with all the cables attached? If breakage is an issue, why buy one cable for £200 when you could buy 100 for £2?

So beware the HDMI thieves and if you’ve already splashed out on a fancy HDMI cable, don’t beat yourself up, millions of marketing dollars were spent convincing you to do so.

 

 

Did you know that there are still some people out there who watch Sky HD by passing it through their VCR in a SCART loop? Yup.

People often get themselves all tangled up (yes I said it) when it comes to cables. How do we know which is the right one to buy, and once we’ve decided, how much should we spend? Below is a short basic guide to cables from a gaming perspective which will hopefully help you make the right choice when looking to get the best from your retro or modern gaming console.

The RF Lead

A Sega RF Unit
A Sega RF Unit

(bundled with the NES, Sega Master System, Sega Megadrive, Super Nintendo, Sony Playstation, Sega Saturn, Nintendo 64, Sega Dreamcast and many more)

The RF lead is perhaps the lowest quality cable you can use for any system. It was shipped with most consoles in the 90’s because it was pretty much guaranteed to work with any Television set. It plugged directly into the antenna socket and offered a pass-through for your existing Terrestrial TV aerial. It wasn’t a plug and play solution requiring you to tune your TV to the correct frequency in order to see any video output. The quality suffers because both analogue video and sound are compressed into one cable. Additionally all of the video information (Red Green Blue and Brightness) were sent over one channel.

 

Composite

The deceptive Composite cable
The deceptive Composite cable

(Bundled with Playstation 2, Nintendo Gamecube, Microsoft Xbox, Microsoft Xbox 360, Sony Playstation 3)

If you were a gamer in the 90’s or early 2000’s and you went for a Composite cable as your solution, you were at the very least stepping in the right direction. The appearance of the cable gave the impression that you were doing your utmost best for you console, with the three separated plugs, satisfyingly snug in the back of the TV, surely this was the bees knees of audio video cables? Wrong. From an audio perspective the Composite cable did a great job. The red and white cables offered full stereo support and could even pass through Dolby Pro-Logic to a dedicated receiver. The downfall however is in the video connection. Only a step up from RF, it offered a cleaner picture but the RGB and Brightness channels were still being fed through one connection compressed and muted.

 

S-Video

The horrendously boring yet capable S-Video cable
The horrendously boring yet capable S-Video cable

Used more internationally than in the UK S-Video is a slight step up from Composite in that the RGB channels and brightness are carried on separate connections, more information to the television made for a better image overall. For people in the states who do not have access to SCART, then this is the go to cable for retro gaming.

SCART/RGB Scart

A wild RGB SCART cable appeared, note the full set of pins
A wild RGB SCART cable appeared, note the full set of pins

(RGB available on: Super Nintendo, Sega Megadrive, Neo Geo AES, Sega Saturn, Sega Dreamcast, PS2, Gamecube, Xbox)

SCART was a french/european standard which became a massive success on the continent but failed to make much of an impact in the rest of the world. Although the connectors are big and bulky, a fully wired RGB SCART Cable is without a doubt the best way to play classic consoles on a CRT TV, all of the RGB and Brightness channels are fed independently as is the stereo sound. The picture will be as clean and pure as it can be. There are some things to watch out for. As standard, the Nintendo 64 for example cannot output RGB video and in some circumstances no video will be seen at all when using a fully wired SCART cable, in which case a standard SCART can be used (pins will be missing from the connector) however you’ll essentially be using composite just in a different format. The two different types of SCART cable trip up people on a regular basis so it’s always worth checking the pins before you buy. The Megadrive, SNES, PS1, Neo Geo, Saturn & Dreamcast all support RGB start out of the box so if you own one of these consoles and you’re still using RF or Composite, you’re an idiot.

Component Cables

Component cable without audio leads
Component cable without audio leads

(Compatible with PS2 (certain titles), Xbox, Xbox 360, PS3, Gamecube)

This is where it starts getting interesting. A component cable is one of the few analogue cables capable of transmitting HD quality video to your television. Component cables do not carry any audio and all three leads are dedicated to RGB along with a few other signals that ensure correct fidelity. With a component cable you can get 1080p from a PS3 or an Xbox 360 and even the Gamecube and PS2 can output high quality signal depending on the game (the US version of Gran Turismo 4 is a fine example). The only downsides to component are the price and lack of HDCP support meaning any copy protected HD content (including games) will not display. If component is your only option, or you want to get the absolute best from your early 2000 gen hardware then don’t feel down. They provide fantastic picture quality and more often than not the cables are provided with an audio solution too!

HDMI

Thankfully HDMI is becoming the standard for modern consoles and devices. Providing picture perfect HD video and audio, it’s by far the best solution for connecting a console if it’s available. You needn’t worry on the quality of the cable, as long as it works you’re doing just fine.

Honorable mention: The Dreamcast VGA cable

The Sega Dreamcast was an awesome machine, with pioneering internet capabilities and a fantastic library of games, it’s an Out Of Control favourite. One of its dirty little secrets however is the inclusion of VGA support for some titles. If you can track one down, they’re well worth the effort. The VGA cable will provide a 480p output with an incredibly clear image. This does mean you’ll have to feed the audio into your TV or home cinema in a different way but most of the popular VGA adapters for Dreamcast will provide a myriad of solutions.

A cheap and easy solution such as this can be bought for as little as £11 on Amazon

What if I want to use old consoles on modern TV’s?

A good question. On most TV’s, fully wired RGB SCART will look pretty acceptable, but you’re still going to be stretching the original output to a resolution way beyond what was ever intended. A good solution for this is an Upscaler. These clever little boxes take whatever video you put in and convert them to a high quality HD image using a range of filtering techniques to make the video look as good as possible. They’re not perfect but they can make retro gaming on an HD TV a little more pleasant. Here at OOC we use one of these. It’s cheap and cheerful and although there are better devices out there on the market such as the X-RGB, it does a pretty good job. The only thing you have to ensure is that you’re putting in the highest quality video you can so RGB SCART is always recommended where possible.